Semester project overview
Instructions for graduate students
The goal for this project is for you to implement a complete open–source reproduction of an important research paper from your dissertation field. The general steps to completing this project are as follows:
Identify a published paper whose key results you would like to reproduce, and whose reproduction seems feasible.1.
Secure the dataset generated in the original study, either directly from the paper or by contacting the authors.
Reproduce, to the best of your abilities, the analyses and figures presented in the original publication. Your work on this reproduction analysis should be tracked with version control, and the final report should be in the form of a
qmd
document.Write a report that describes (i) the motivation, methods, and results of the original publication; (ii) the steps you took to reproduce these results, including any problems that got in the way of your reproduction; (iii) what you learned from the reproduction exercise.
1 We will discuss characteristics of “good” paper to reproduce in class
Instructions for undergraduate students
Undergraduate students will choose an openly available dataset that you find interesting (e.g. from this repository), and create two non-trivial visualizations2 As above, undergraduate students will write a report that describes (i) the motivation and methods that went into collecting the original dataset; (ii) the steps you took to generate your figures, including any problems that got in the way; (iii) what you learned from the exercise.
2 Here, I take “non-trivial” to mean something more than just plotting data from two existing columns against one another.
Grading
Your final grade will be determined as follows:
- Proposal presentation (5 minutes each; scheduled for 13 March): 10 points
- Final project presentation (15 minutes each with 5 for questions; scheduled for Apr 22–29): 20 points
- Final writeup (due by 1 May): 50 points
- Participation and engagement: 20 points.
Further details for each will be provided as the semester progresses.